Showing posts with label Antonin Artaud. Show all posts
Showing posts with label Antonin Artaud. Show all posts

Wednesday, November 26, 2014

Interlude XXXIII. Foucault - part 13

The Ship of Fools




Intro & Preface & Contents

Previous: Interlude XXXII. Foucault - part 12




From The Passion of Michel Foucault by James Miller...




Chapter 4 - The Castle of Murders cont...


The Ship of Fools.


Foucault tacitly acknowledges that he is painting a mythic picture. In these very years, he concedes in passing, “certain madmen,” far from roaming the countryside, were “admitted to hospitals and cared for as such.” Indeed, “in the majority of the cities of Europe there existed throughout the Middle Ages and Renaissance a place of detention reserved for the insane.”


It is easy to miss such scholarly qualifications, however, since Foucault directs the reader’s attention elsewhere, above all to what becomes the book’s guiding image: the Ship of Fools. This is, “of course,” as Foucault stresses, “a literary composition” -- a fanciful emblem, the subject of one of Bosch’s most famous paintings [a little surprising Foucault didn’t go with Bosch’s “Death and the Miser” instead], a “bateau ivre” or “drunken boat” more redolent, in Foucault’s hands, of Rimbaud’s poetry than of any real Renaissance practice. And yet, as Foucault emphasizes, “they did exist, these boats that conveyed their insane cargo from one city to another.” “The simplest of pictures,” [there's that "simplest" again] the Ship of Fools is “the most symbolic as well,” straddling the line between dream and reality.


I have to say that it isn’t obvious to me that Bosch’s drunken boat has anything to do with madness at all, except in the pious Christian sense that it is madness to seek pleasure in this life rather than in the next. A little more searching reveals that the term “Ship of Fools” has always been used allegorically, starting with Plato. To me this is like Foucault suggesting there may have been an actual cave with actual shadows where a very confused person was chained. Or in the language of the SnarkSquad, I’m calling shenanigans.


I also can’t resist quoting this from Wiki about the Ship of Fools,


This concept makes up the framework of the 15th century book Ship of Fools (1494) by Sebastian Brant, which served as the inspiration for Hieronymous Bosch's famous painting, Ship of Fools: a ship—an entire fleet at first—sets off from Basel to the paradise of fools..



May I remind the reader that, at the time he wrote The Birth of Tragedy, Nietzsche was a professor of philology at Basel.



“The custom,” Foucault writes, “was especially frequent in Germany.... In Frankfurt in 1399, seamen were instructed to rid the city of a madman who walked about the streets naked; in the first years of the fifteenth century, a criminal madman was expelled in the same manner from Mainz.”


Using as a factual pretext these two minor recorded incidents, and intertwining an interpretation of Bosch’s imagery, Foucault constructs an intricate aquatic reverie, linking madness with water “and the dark mass of its own values.” Water “carries off,” but it also “purifies.” If solid ground has conventionally been associated with reason, water has for centuries been the symbolic element of unreason: “Madness is the liquid and streaming exterior of rocky reason,” and water an “infinite, uncertain space,” the oceanic element of “dark disorder” and “a moving chaos.”

We will return to this conception of the "oceanic" in our final part on Foucault. And may I observe how quaint it is that Frankfurt and Mainz, at that time, could be perceptibly improved by the removal of a single lunatic. Here it would require the removal of a thousand to even be noticed.


That is why the image of the ship setting sail is so well suited to evoke the daimonic forces at play in every person’s life: “Navigation delivers man to the uncertainty of fate; on water, each of us is in the hands of his own destiny.” Particularly for the madman who has ironically “tamed” death, “every embarkation is, potentially, the last.” While the madman preoccupied with death has “his truth,” he can discover it only in “that fruitless expanse” beyond “the solid land, with its solid cities,” casting himself adrift like “a skiff, abandoned on the infinite sea of desire.” Once underway on this quest, “there is no escape”: the madman is “delivered to that great uncertainty external to everything. He is a prisoner in the most free of domains, the openest of routes: bound fast at the infinite crossroads.”


Was Foucault a fan of Melville one wonders? Or Conrad?


p101
The image of this emblematic “dream fleet” filled with “highly symbolic cargoes of madmen in search of their reason,” Foucault argues, arises at a singular moment in Western history: a transitional [liminal?] era when the symbolism of medieval paintings and sculpture had become so complex that “the picture no longer speaks for itself.” The canvases of Bosch, with their fantastic monsters and demented forms, were meant in part to convey a theology; but to the Renaissance imagination (or is Foucault perhaps again surreptitiously referring to himself?) they communicate instead, “by an astonishing reversal,” the “phantasms of madness.”


A bestiality formerly domesticated “by human symbols and values” stands revealed as “the secret nature of man,” exposing “the dark rage, the sterile madness that lie in men’s hearts.” In Bosch’s “pure vision,” especially once that vision has been cut off from its symbolic association with faith, madness reveals all of its glory, and “deploys its powers. Phantasms and menaces, pure appearance of the dream and secret destiny of the world -- madness here retains the primitive force of revelation: revelation that the dream is real,” and that “the entire reality of the world will one day be reabsorbed in a fantastic Image,” in an apocalyptic commingling of “being and nothingness that is the delirium of pure destruction.”


We must now imagine the Ship of Fools sailing toward one of Bosch’s fiery and infernal landscapes -- a paradoxical paradise “where all is offered to desire,” yet torture, death, and the End of Time still looms, ever present. For “when man deploys the arbitrary nature of his madness,” Foucault contends, he discovers no Rousseauian domain of innocent freedom, but rather “the dark necessity of the world; the animal that haunts his nightmares and his nights of privation is his own nature, which will lay bare the pitiless truth of Hell.”


This seems to me to be another aspect of Man creating God in his own image. That the Holocaust, and other 20th century abominations, were created by men precisely to fill the void left by doubt in an actual Hell with a man-made hell in this life, is not a new idea.


The Ship of Fools thus becomes, as it were, the central panel in a triptych, flanked by a picture of a desolate void on one side -- and a scene of the Last Judgement, teeming with the agonized grimaces of the damned, on the other.


A complication arises. That Renaissance thinkers regarded madness with unwonted sympathy Foucault easily shows through an interpretation of Erasmus and Montaigne. But in the humanist treatments of madness -- above all, in Erasmus’s Praise of Folly -- Foucault finds the roots of what he regards as the modern era’s condescension toward the mad: “Whereas Bosch, Brueghel [I assume he means Pieter the Elder], and Dürer were fearfully terrestrial spectators, implicated in that madness they saw surging around them, Erasmus observes it from far enough away to be out of danger.”


p102


Foucault detects a subtle fault-line. Two divergent approaches to madness are in the process of forming: the “tragic experience’ communicated by Bosch, and a “critical consciousness,” first formulated by Erasmus. “On the one hand, there will be a Ship of Fools, filled with wild faces, that little by little sinks into the night of the world, traversing a landscape that speaks of the strange alchemy of knowledge, the pressing menace of bestiality, and the end of time. On the other, there will be a Ship of Fools that forms for the wise the exemplary, and didactic, Odyssey of human faults.”


I have a couple problems with that last sentence. Why is “Odyssey” capitalized? The Odyssey is the name of a book attributed to Homer. The word “odyssey,” according to Merriam-Webster means “1 : a long wandering or voyage usually marked by many changes of fortune. 2 : an intellectual or spiritual wandering or quest.” “Didactic” means “intended to teach, particularly in having moral instruction as an ulterior motive” according to Google. “Exemplary,” again according to Google, means either “1. serving as a desirable model; representing the best of its kind...” or “2. (of a punishment) serving as a warning or deterrent.” Could this be rephrased as “On the other hand, there will be a Ship of Fools that forms, for the wise, an, exemplary and didactic, odyssey of human faults”? Even if there's a comma missing between "wise" and "the," I still don't know what this is supposed to mean. And I will remind the reader -- as I was confused at first -- that by “the pressing menace of bestiality” Foucault has in mind men becoming more like beasts, not, and I hesitate to say this with reference to a book about Foucault, anything sexual. Or at least that's the way Miller has been using the term.



The “humanist” praise of folly, in Foucault’s view, thus inaugurates a long tradition that will seek to define, control, and ultimately “confiscate” the experience of madness. This tradition -- culminating in psychoanalysis four centuries later -- tries to make of madness an experience in which the human being is constantly confronted with “his moral truth,” revealing “the rules proper to his nature,” turning “what was formerly a visible fortress of order” into “the castle of our conscience.” The result is “not a radical destruction” -- madness and unreason persist -- “but only an occultation.” The “tragic figures” of madness painted by Bosch, and brought back to life on stage by Artaud what night in January, 1947, are cast “into the shade.”


Foucault quotes Artaud directly: “the Humanism of the Renaissance was not an enlargement, but rather a diminution of man.”


The story that Foucault will tell in the body of this book is nuanced, complex, intricate. But the allegory of the first chapter conveys its essence. For what is ultimately at stake in Madness and Civilization is as subtle as the difference between Bosch and Erasmus -- and as vivid (and problematic) as Artaud’s last public outburst.


Will figures of “tragic experience” like Artaud continue to be confined in the dungeons of modern society, held prisoner in the castles built by moral conscience?


Or will a new Ship of Fools, like that painted by Bosch before the dawn of the Age of Reason, set sail again, ferrying its cargo of contemporary outcasts (”the debauched, the dissipated, the homosexual, the magician, the suicide, the libertine”) over the boundaries of custom and morality, destination unknown?

Living, as I do, on streets of unreason, I think I can answer that last question. Just yesterday I found a great seat at a table in the Bank Cafe closest to the corner, overlooking sidewalks on two sides of the building and the intersection beyond. Whenever I looked up there seemed to be one and sometimes two obviously deranged persons navigating the crowded sidewalks. Some were ranting to themselves. Some just looked confused and overwhelmed. I would be tempted to use the word "bestial" to describe the way their lives appear to me, when we pass on the streets, but perhaps the reality is different for them.

I didn’t realize when I started this book that Foucault is the philosophical father of "Care in the Community." Madness has found a home here and we have learned to live (warily) with madness. They do keep us on our toes and add a little color and plot to our streets.



Monday, November 24, 2014

Interlude XXXI. Foucault - part 11 - Antonin Artaud



Intro & Preface & Contents

Previous: Interlude XXX. Foucault - part 10





From The Passion of Michel Foucault by James Miller...



Chapter 4 - The Castle of Murders

Antonin Artaud.


p94
It had been advertized as a “tête-à-tête with Antonin Artaud.” and the overflow audience packed into the small Paris theater on January 24, 1947, gaped in wonder. On stage was one of the most storied figures of the pre-war Parisian avant-garde. A decade before, the actor and artist had announced his plans to create a new kind of drama, a new type of theatrical performance -- a display of delirium designed to “stir up shadows” and to spark, as if by contagion, “a spasm in which life is continually lacerated,” convulsing the spectator “with the truthful precipitates of dreams, in which his taste for crime, his erotic obsessions, his savagery, his chimeras, his utopian sense of life and matter, even his cannibalism pour out, on a level not counterfeit and illusory, but interior."


That night in 1947, something like Artaud's improbable plans for a “theater of cruelty” came strangely, disturbingly to life. Only a few months before, he had been a patient in a psychiatric hospital in Rodez; for most of the previous decade, he had been continuously confined in various mental institutions. He had not performed in public since 1935. Nobody knew what to expect.


The actor read poems. Even his closest friends could understand little of what Artaud was saying: hermetic, strange, his incantations boiled with visceral rage. “The anchored mind,” he declaimed, “screwed into me by the psycho-lubricious thrust of heaven is the one that thinks every temptation, every desire, every inhibition..."


p95
The man on stage would not let his audience ignore his pain, his suffering, his nine years of psychiatric confinement, the more than sixty convulsive shock treatments he had been forced to undergo.


"If there had been no doctors there would never have been any sick people,” he raved on. “Death too must live; and there's nothing like an insane asylum to tenderly incubate death.” “War will replace the father-mother.” “There rises again the old warrior of the insurgent cruelty, the unspeakable cruelty of living and having no being that can justify you."


Repeatedly, he fell silent. He seemed lost. Repeatedly, he started over.


And so it went for almost three hours, hands flying, words tumbling, silent pauses creating a mounting sense of apprehension.


Then, an accident; in a sweeping gesture, Artaud knocked over the papers he was reading. Stopping, he bent down to retrieve the manuscript. His glasses fell off. He dropped to his knees. Groping blindly, he searched for his poetry.


"We were all in extreme anguish,” one old friend later recalled. “He told us afterward that the void in the room made him afraid."


"Partial panic convulsed the audience,” another spectator remembered.


Sitting in the front row was André Gide, at seventy-eight the dean of French letters. From his seat, he tried to show Artaud where his manuscript had fallen.


It was no use. Slowly, unsteadily, the actor, as if suddenly a broken man, lifted himself up and sank back into his seat. “I put myself in your place,” he said, “and I can see that what I tell you isn't at all interesting. It's still theater. What can one do to be truly sincere?"


The show was over. With the help of a neighbor, Gide rose to his feet, walked on stage, embraced Artaud, and guided him to the wings. It was Artaud's last public appearance, fourteen months later, he was dead.


p96
The questions raised by Artaud's “tete-a-tete” are the questions at the heart of Foucault's first great book -- Folie et deraison ("Madness and Unreason,” re-titled in English as Madness and Civilization).


Was the great actor simply out of his mind? Or -- bizarre idea -- was he, as Foucault would imply, a modern prophet like Nietzsche's Zarathustra?


As André Gide later recalled, the audience leaving the theater that night “remained silent. What could they say? They had just seen an unhappy man, fearfully shaken by a god."


André Breton lamented the exploitation of a pathetically sick artist. Another writer deplored “the atrocious bad taste in the exhibition of such misery."


Gide, however, concluded that it was Artaud's finest hour: “Never before had be seemed so admirable to me."

He certainly seemed admirable to Michel Foucault. As he suggested in countless allusions and references throughout Madness and Civilization, Artaud was a figure of daimonic heroism, an artist who embodied a new way of knowing. He had conveyed his uncanny genius through the modern alchemy of poetry and drama, convulsively [ !! ] expressing his apparent madness in a singular work, precisely in Blanchot's strong sense -- and particularly on that night in 1947. Improvising a unified performance that breached the boundaries between acting and being, artifice and uncontrollable impulse, Artaud had put his mind to the test, unforgettably evoking for his audience, as Foucault later put it, “that space of physical suffering and terror which surrounds or rather coincides with the void."


This was in the local newspaper recently and I immediately thought of Artaud and Foucault. I'm going to quote it in full:

Mike Daisey is currently in the middle of a run at the California Shakespeare Theater in Orinda. He’s taking on four of Shakespeare’s tragedies on four consecutive nights; the second week of his run is Thursday through Sunday. Last week, I saw his “Hamlet.”
It was not his most finished work; a few of his threads kind of dangled off. But with Daisey, everything is a work in progress. He works from notes, not a script. He’s a wonderful talker; a wonderful shaper of thoughts. His “Hamlet” was about a whole bunch of things. The Chronicle’s Robert Hurwitt has a review of the show available online if you’re curious for more.
One of the things that his performance delved into was his bouts with depression and suicidal ideation. He tells of being (briefly) placed in a mental institution. And he points out that “To be or not to be” is a very straightforward speech about suicide.
And then he begins talking in the dark, about what the purpose of theater is, and about the allure of death. It was all mixed in. And as he talked, the stage lights got dimmer and dimmer. Eventually he was in complete darkness, his figure silhouetted by the oak and bay trees behind the Cal Shakes stage. And still he kept talking. He kept being a voice in the darkness, reaching out to us, encouraging us to become engaged in the theatrical process, to feel the darkness descending as the hero speaks frankly about suicide.
And right at the end of that, someone in the audience stood up and said, “You’re boring.” And, then, walking out, he yelled, “Hamlet is great, but you’re boring.” Then someone else in the audience yelled, “You had us in the palm of your hand, Mike.” Then the houselights came up, and Daisey laughed.
There’s not much to say about this event in terms of behavior. As Hurwitt tweeted, “Walking out of a show is yr right. Walking out and loudly voicing yr opinion is rude 2 everyone present. Also arrogant.” That pretty much says it. But what interested me more was this: It was a total freak-out. I suspect the heckler may have been a little disoriented by the whole process; Daisey is definitely not standard Cal Shakes fare. Perhaps he expected an academic disquisition on “Hamlet;” I dunno.
But when it got dark, he got panicky. He couldn’t watch anymore. He had some kind of powerful resentment — so powerful that he forgot basic theater manners — and he needed to express it.
We’ve all been to bad theater. We may have been bewildered by the laughter in the audience about something distinctly not funny. We may even have left at intermission, or just plain walked out. But we figure: Different strokes for different folks. Yelling is different; it indicates an intense level of engagement. In other words, the heckler was having a theatrical experience. It was a negative experience, but it was real. It demanded immediate attention. I’ve seen so many shows that were meant to be shocking, and they weren’t. Intercourse onstage, simulated or real? Seen it. Murder? Been there. Rape? Saw that too. Generally, I was not shocked. Attempts to provoke can seem pathetic.
But a demand for introspection in a darkened space? That was too much. Our heckler had to get the hell out of Dodge, and right now. And that’s genuine. When people rioted the premiere of “Le Sacre du Printemps,” they were engaged. The music mattered. A corruption of the form (as they would see it) mattered.
Daisey does intend to provoke. Even when it’s hard on him (he seemed a little shaken after the incident), he does that job. He made the theater come alive.

-Jon Carroll - "And so we heard a voice in the dark"