Showing posts with label Apollinian. Show all posts
Showing posts with label Apollinian. Show all posts

Sunday, November 16, 2014

Interlude XXIII. Nietzsche - part 12

Parable of the porcupines




Intro & Preface & Contents

Previous: Interlude XXII. Nietzsche - part 11




From The Birth of Tragedy by Friedrich Nietzsche...



Sec 22 -

...He [the attentive “friend”] beholds the transfigured world of the stage and nevertheless denies it. He sees the tragic hero before him in epic clearness and beauty, and nevertheless rejoices in his annihilation. He comprehends the action deep down, and yet likes to flee into the incomprehensible. He feels the actions of the hero to be justified, and is nevertheless still more elated when these actions annihilate their agent. He shudders at the sufferings which befall the hero, and yet anticipates in them a higher, much more overpowering joy. He sees more extensively and profoundly than ever, and yet wishes he were blind.


Again this is so Japanese and so consonant with the death wish aspect of Schubert that Mann was mining in The Magic Mountain. Plus the sublime aspect of suffering resonates with some of Naphtha’s positions..


How must we derive this curious internal bifurcation, this blunting of the Apollinian point, if not from the Dionysian magic that, though apparently exciting the Apollinian emotions to their highest pitch, still retains the power to force into its service his excess of Apollinian force?


The tragic myth is to be understood only as a symbolization of the Dionysian wisdom through Apollinian artifices. The myth leads the world of phenomena to its limits where it denies itself and seeks to flee back again into the warmth of the true and only reality, where it then seems to commence its metaphysical swansong...  [I’m skipping the Isolde reference here.]


[Talking about the problem for the dramatic artist of performing for an audience of “critics” -- of people educated to view art dispassionately,] ...Confronted with such a public, the nobler natures among the artists counted upon exciting their moral-religious emotions, and the appeal to the moral world-order intervened vicariously where some powerful artistic magic ought to enrapture the genuine listener. Or some more imposing, or at all events exciting, trend of the contemporary political and social world was so vividly presented by the dramatist that the listener could forget his critical exhaustion and abandon himself to emotions similar to those felt in patriotic or warlike moments, or before the tribune of parliament, or at the condemnation of crime and vice -- an alienation from the true aims of art that sometimes had to result in an outright cult of tendentiousness... The attempt, for example, to use the theater as an institution for the moral education of the people, still taken seriously in Schiller’s time, is already reckoned among the incredible antiques of a dated type of education. While the critic got the upper hand in the theater and concert hall, the journalist in the schools, and the press in society, art degenerated into a particularly lowly topic of conversation, and aesthetic criticism was used as a means of uniting a vain, distracted, selfish, and moreover piteously unoriginal sociability whose character is suggested by Schopenhauer’s parable of the porcupines. As a result art has never been so much talked about and so little esteemed....


I adore Schopenhauer’s parable of the porcupines so I’m going to quote it in full: On a cold day, a group of porcupines huddled together closely to save themselves by their mutual warmth from freezing. But soon felt the mutual quills and drew apart. Whenever the need for warmth brought them closer together again, this second evil was repeated, so that they were tossed back and forth between these two kinds of suffering until they discovered a moderate distance that proved most tolerable -- Thus the need for company, born of the emptiness and monotony inside them, drives men together; but their many revolting qualities and intolerable faults repel them again. The medium distance that they finally discover and that makes association possible is politeness and good manners. Whoever does not keep this distance is told, among the British: keep your distance! -- To be sure, this only permits imperfect satisfaction of the need for mutual warmth, but it also keeps one from feeling the prick of the quills -- But whoever possesses much inner warmth of his own will prefer to avoid company lest he cause or suffer annoyance.

Henry Ryecroft would have been a porcupine with great "inner warmth."




Saturday, November 15, 2014

Interlude XXII. Nietzsche - part 11

Music... the real idea of the world




Intro & Preface & Contents

Previous: Interlude XXI. Nietzsche - part 10



From The Birth of Tragedy by Friedrich Nietzsche...



Sec 20 - Rebirth of tragedy (Sec 19 was about opera...)

...If heroes like Goethe and Schiller could not succeed in breaking open the enchanted gate which leads into the Hellenic magic mountain... what could the epigones of such heroes hope for -- unless, amid the mystic tones of reawakening tragic music, the gate should open for them suddenly of its own accord....


Let no one try to blight our faith in a yet-impending rebirth of Hellenic antiquity; for this alone gives us hope for a rebirth and purification of the German spirit through the fire magic of music....


Yes, my friends, believe with me in Dionysian life and the rebirth of tragedy. The age of the Socratic man is over... Only dare to be tragic men; for you are to be redeemed....


This, once again, sounds like the voice of the true Nietzsche.


Sec 21 - Music and Tragedy

[Speaking again of the Greeks,] ...It is the people of the tragic mysteries that fights the battles against the Persians; and the people that fought these wars in turn needs tragedy as a necessary potion to recover... After all, one feels in every case in which the Dionysian liberation from the fetters of the individual finds expression first of all in a diminution of, in indifference to, indeed, in hostility to, the political instincts. Just as certainly, Apollo who forms states is also the genius of the principium individuationis, and state and patriotism cannot live without an affirmation of the individual personality. [National Socialism would contradict this, I think, or rather, would see in National Socialism a middle ground perhaps] But from orgies a people can take one path only, the path to Indian Buddhism, and in order that this may be endurable at all with its yearning for the nothing, it requires these rare ecstatic states with their elevation above space, time, and the individual. These states in turn demand a philosophy that teaches men how to overcome by the force of an idea the indescribable displeasure of the states that lie between. Where the political drives are taken to be absolutely valid, it is just as necessary that a people should go the path toward the most extreme secularization whose most magnificent but also most terrifying expression may be found in the Roman imperium.


...But let us ask by means of what remedy it was possible for the Greeks during their greatest period, in spite of the extraordinary strength of their Dionysian and political instincts, not to exhaust themselves either in ecstatic brooding or in a consuming chase after worldly power and worldly honor, but rather to attain that splendid mixture which resembles a noble wine in making one feel fiery and contemplative at the same time. Here we must clearly think of the tremendous power that stimulated, purified, and discharged the whole life of the people: tragedy....


First, it’s impossible to generalize about the Hellenes as they were so different. I assume he is primarily talking about the Athenians but it wasn’t the Athenians alone who fought the Persians. Second, Athenian values were well mixed with greed and the usual failings of mankind. The democracy of Athens intrigues us because it is such a true mirror of our own vices.


Tragedy absorbs the highest ecstasies of music, so that it truly brings music, both among the Greeks and among us, to its perfection; but then it places the tragic myth and the tragic hero next to it, and he, like a powerful Titan, takes the whole Dionysian world upon his back and thus relieves us of this burden. [The Promethean/Christ thing again] On the other hand, by means of the same tragic myth, in the person of the tragic hero, it knows how to redeem us from the greedy thirst for this existence, and with an admonishing gesture it reminds us of another existence and a higher pleasure for which the struggling hero prepares himself by means of his destruction, not by means of his triumphs. [Now the Japanese are on board. Also, this does work with National Socialism, personal transcendence through sacrifice for the nation. And nothing could be more anti-bourgeois.] Between the universal validity of its music and the listener, receptive in his Dionysian state, tragedy places a sublime parable, the myth, and deceives the listener into feeling that the music is merely the highest means to bring life into the vivid world of myth. Relying on this noble deception, it may now move its limbs in dithyrambic dances and yield unhesitatingly to an ecstatic feeling of freedom in which it could not dare to wallow as pure music without this deception. The myth protects us against the music, while on the other hand it alone gives music the highest freedom. In return, music imparts to the tragic myth an intense and convincing metaphysical significance that word and image without this singular help could never have attained. And above all, it is through music that the tragic spectator is overcome by an assured premonition of a highest pleasure attained through destruction and negation, so he feels as if the innermost abyss of things spoke to him perceptibly...


That not only would be of interest to the Japanese and National Socialists but it is starting to make me think of Schubert’s Winterreise which brings us back to Hans Castorp and The Magic Mountain.


Suppose a human being has thus put his ear, as it were, to the heart chamber of the world will [by listening to the third act of Tristan and Isolde] and felt the roaring desire for existence pouring from there into all the veins of the world, as a thundering current or as the gentlest brook, dissolving into a mist -- how could he fail to break suddenly? How could he endure to perceive the echo of innumerable shouts of pleasure and woe in the ‘wide space of the world night,’ enclosed in the wretched glass capsule of the human individual, [sounds a bit like Goethe's Homunculus] without inexorably fleeing toward his primordial home, as he hears this shepherd's dance of metaphysics? But if such a work could nevertheless be perceived as a whole, without denial of individual existence; if such a creation could be created without smashing its creator -- whence do we take the solution of such a contradiction?


I’d like to skip over some of this but it seems I really can’t.


Here the tragic myth and the tragic hero intervene between our highest musical emotion and this music -- at bottom only as symbols of the most universal facts, of which only music can speak so directly. [I keep thinking back to the Cosmic Music of String Theory] But if our feelings were those of entirely Dionysian beings, myth as a symbol would remain totally ineffective and unnoticed, and would never for a moment keep us from listening to the re-echo of the universalia ante rem...” [I’m also getting insight on the Medieval virtue, as well as necessity, of copying manuscripts as I type this out. No better way to really learn them. A passage about how Apollinian factors distance us from the Dionysian reality,] ”And where, breathless, we once thought we were being extinguished in a convulsive distention of all our feelings, and little remained to tie us to our present existence, we now hear and see only the hero wounded to death, yet not yet dying, with his despairing cry: ‘Longing! Longing! In death still longing! for very longing not dying!’ ...However powerfully pity affects us, it nevertheless saves us in a way from the primordial suffering of the world, just as the symbolic image of the myth saves us from the immediate perception of the highest world idea, [So the Apollinian is what keeps us from really seeing Annie Dillard’s “Lights in the Tree.” Yes that is a bit of a stretch,] just as thought and word save us from the uninhibited effusion of the unconscious will. The glorious Apollinian illusion makes it appear as if even the tone world confronted us as a sculptural world....


Thus the Apollinian tears us out of the Dionysian universality and lets us find delight in individuals; it attaches our pity to them, and by means of them it satisfies our sense of beauty which longs for great and sublime forms; it presents images of life to us, and incites us to comprehend in thought the core of life they contain. With the immense impact of the image, the concept, the ethical teaching, and the sympathetic emotion, the Apollinian tears man from his orgiastic self-annihilation and blinds him to the universality of the Dionysian process, deluding him into the belief that he is seeing a single image of the world... and that, through music, he is merely supposed to see it still better and more profoundly. What can the healing magic of Apollo not accomplish when it can even create the illusion that the Dionysian is really in the service of the Apollinian and capable of enhancing its effects -- as if music were essentially the art of presenting an Apollinian content?


...music is the real idea of the world, drama is but the reflection of this idea, a single silhouette of it... Even if we agitate and enliven the figure [character] in the most visible manner, and illuminate it from within, it still remains merely a phenomenon from which no bridge leads us to true reality, into the heart of the world. But music speaks out of this heart; and though countless phenomena of the kind were to accompany this music, they could never exhaust its essence, but would always be nothing more than its externalized copies.

...In the total effect of tragedy, the Dionysian predominates once again. Tragedy closes with a sound which could never come from the realm of Apollinian art. And thus Apollinian illusion reveals itself as what it really is -- the veiling during the performance of the tragedy of the real Dionysian effect; but the latter is so powerful that it ends by forcing the Apollinian drama itself into a sphere where it begins to speak with Dionysian wisdom and even denies itself and its Apollinian visibility. Thus the intricate relation of the Apollinian and the Dionysian in tragedy may really be symbolized by a fraternal union of the two deities: Dionysus speaks the language of Apollo; and Apollo, finally the language of Dionysus; and so the highest goal of tragedy and of all art is attained.





Wednesday, November 5, 2014

Interlude XIII. Nietzsche - part 2 - mere appearance



Intro & Preface & Contents

Previous: Interlude XII. Nietzsche - part 1





From The Birth of Tragedy by Friedrich Nietzsche...


Sec 4 - mere appearance of mere appearance


...Though it is certain that of the two halves of our existence, the waking and the dreaming states, the former appeals to us as infinitely preferable, more important, excellent, and worthy of being lived, indeed, as that alone which is lived -- yet in relation to that mysterious ground of our being of which we are the phenomena, I should, paradoxically as it may seem, maintain the very opposite estimate of the value of dreams. For the more clearly I perceive in nature those omnipotent art impulses, and in them an ardent longing for illusion, for redemption through illusion, the more I feel myself impelled to the metaphysical assumption that the truly existent primal unity, eternally suffering and contradictory, also needs the rapturous vision, the pleasurable illusion, for its continuous redemption. And we, completely wrapped up in this illusion and composed of it, are compelled to consider this illusion as the truly nonexistent -- i.e., as a perpetual becoming in time, space, and causality -- in other words, as empirical reality. If, for the moment, we do not consider the question of our own ‘reality,’ if we conceive of our empirical existence, and of that of the world in general, as a continuously manifested representation of the primal unity, we shall then have to look upon the dream as a mere appearance of mere appearance, hence as a still higher appeasement of the primordial desire for mere appearance. And that is why the innermost heart of nature feels ineffable joy in the naive artist and the naive work of art, which is likewise only ‘mere appearance of mere appearance.’


I can’t help feeling that this relates to Hans's dream in “Snow” (in The Magic Mountain). Also, as I am very interested in dreams, the relative reality of dreams, and also the nature of the dreamer, I find this passage particularly interesting.


Nietzsche seems to claim to understand his dreams better than has been my experience -- I am most often puzzled at best and often completely confused -- but what I find interesting is that in dreams “I” am able to create, seemingly instantaneously and with no effort, entire worlds that I could not draw or model while awake if you gave me days or weeks. This struck me years ago when I spent several weeks walking around my new neighborhood with a camera snapping photos of particularly fine architectural details. In a dream I ran into a truly wonderful such architectural feature inside a building and was irritated that I didn’t have my camera with me to capture something so beautiful and so beyond my ability to describe or reproduce. This was the sort of dream where you are at least dimly aware that you are dreaming and the question of “who” created this, if not me, so jarred me that I woke up.



...Because of his titanic love for man, Prometheus must be torn to pieces by vultures; because of his excessive wisdom, which could solve the riddle of the Sphinx, Oedipus must be plunged into a bewildering vortex of crime. Thus did the Delphic god interpret the Greek past.


The effects wrought by the Dionysian also seemed ‘titanic’ and ‘barbaric’ to the Apollinian Greek; while at the same time he could not conceal from himself that he, too, was inwardly related to these overthrown Titans and heroes. Indeed, he had to recognize even more than this: despite all its beauty and moderation, his entire existence rested on a hidden substratum of suffering and of knowledge, revealed to him by the Dionysian. And behold: Apollo could not live without Dionysus! The ‘titanic’ and the ‘barbaric’ were in the last analysis as necessary as the Apollinian.

This passage is particularly interesting when you consider Settembrini’s crusade (ha) to rid the world of suffering. Not only is it Faustian, it is also, from this perspective, futile; suffering -- as perhaps portrayed in Hans's dream in “Snow” -- is the foundation of the Apollinian existence.

And now let us imagine how into this world, built on mere appearance and moderation and artificially dammed up, there penetrated, in tones ever more bewitching and alluring, the ecstatic sound of the Dionysian festival; how in these strains all of nature’s excess in pleasure, grief, and knowledge became audible, even in piercing shrieks... The muses of the arts of ‘illusion’ paled before an art that, in its intoxication, spoke the truth... The individual, with his restraint and proportion, succumbed to the self-oblivion of the Dionysian states, forgetting the precepts of Apollo. Excess revealed itself as truth. Contradiction, the bliss born of pain, spoke out from the very heart of nature. And so wherever the Dionysian prevailed, the Apollinian was checked and destroyed....

Since I came to The Birth of Tragedy looking for connections with The Magic Mountain, it is hard not to see Clavdia and even Peeperkorn in this passage. If Settembrini is the Apollinian then Clavdia is at least a tool, if not an agent of the Dionysian. And Peeperkorn certainly shares qualities with the satyr god.

This section concludes with a passage that talks about the “Doric” or Spartan art as the last vestige and holdout of the pure Apollinian, and of  ”Attic tragedy and the dramatic dithyramb” as the “mysterious union” of the Apollinian and Dionysian tendencies which... “found glorious consummation in this child -- at once Antigone and Cassandra.”


In my edition of the translation by Walter Kaufmann, there is a footnote here referring to a criticism of this passage by Wilamowitz (another young philologist and contemporary of Nietzsche’s) who offers a prize to anyone who can explain what Nietzsche means here about Antigone and Cassandra. I have to admit the man does have a point. Kaufmann thinks Antigone must represent the Apollinian while Cassandra represents the Dionysian. Cassandra happens to be one of my favorite characters in Hellenic myth and drama so my ears pricked up at this passage, but I don’t know what he means either.


Cassandra was given the gift of prophecy by Apollo, as she was a priestess of his. This gift was turned into a curse when she refused the sexual advances of the god, so that no one believed her prophecies. Now the Greeks played fast and loose with their myths to make a point (there are many variations on this story), but the thing I love about the Cassandra story is that it is possibly the only example of prophecy in literature that is handled honestly. The curse is absurd because it is the nature of true prophecy that you can’t change the future, because if you did, then it would not have been the future you saw in the first place. If you announce that your city’s enemies are going to sneak inside the walls by hiding in a big wooden horse -- and people believe you -- how is that horse going to get into the city?


Next: Interlude XIV. Nietzsche - part 3.

Tuesday, November 4, 2014

Interlude XII. Nietzsche - part 1

Apollinian & Dionysian




Intro & Preface & Contents

Previous: Interlude XI. Foucault - part 5



Welcome to the 19th century. From here on out, green text will belong to Friedrich Nietzsche. This will prove helpful when I return to James Miller as he quotes Nietzsche more than he quotes Foucault (or so it seems to me.)


The Birth of Tragedy by Friedrich Nietzsche



Sec 1 - Apollo and Dionysus


...Through Apollo and Dionysus, the two art deities of the Greeks, we come to recognize that in the Greek world there existed a tremendous opposition, in origin and aims, between the Apollinian art of sculpture, and the nonimagistic, Dionysian art of music. These two different tendencies run parallel to each other, for the most part openly at variance; and they continually incite each other to new and more powerful births, which perpetuate an antagonism, only superficially reconciled by the common term 'art'; till eventually, by a metaphysical miracle of the Hellenic 'will,' they appear coupled with each other, and through this coupling ultimately generate an equally Dionysian and Apollinian form of art -- Attic tragedy.


In order to grasp these two tendencies, let us first conceive of them as the separate art worlds of dreams and intoxication. These physiological phenomena present a contrast analogous to that existing between the Apollinian and the Dionysian. It was in dreams, says Lucretius, that the glorious divine figures first appeared to the souls of men; in dreams the great shaper beheld the splendid bodies of superhuman beings; and the Hellenic poet, if questioned about the mysteries of poetic inspiration, would likewise have suggested dreams....


The Apollinian.

The beautiful illusion of the dream worlds, in the creation of which every man is truly an artist, is the prerequisite of all plastic arts, and, as we shall see. of an important part of the poetry also. In our dreams we delight in the immediate understanding of figures; all forms speak to us; there is nothing unimportant or superfluous. But even when this dream reality is most intense, we still have, glimmering through it, the sensation that it is mere appearance: at least this is my experience...


Philosophical men even have a presentment that the reality in which we live and have our being is also mere appearance, and that another, quite different reality lies beneath it...


It is not only the agreeable and friendly images that he experiences as something universally intelligible: the serious, the troubled, the sad, the gloomy, the sudden restraints, the tricks of accident, anxious expectations, in short the whole divine comedy of life, including the inferno, also pass before him, not like mere shadows on a wall -- for he lives and suffers with these scenes -- and yet not without that fleeting sensation of illusion. And perhaps many will, like myself, recall how amid the dangers and terrors of dreams they have occasionally said to themselves in self-encouragement, and not without success: 'It is a dream! I will dream on!' ...


This joyous necessity of the dream experience has been embodied by the Greeks in their Apollo: Apollo, the god of all plastic energies, is at the same time the soothsaying god... the deity of light, is also ruler over the beautiful illusion of the inner world of fantasy. The higher truth, the perfection of these states in contrast to the incompletely intelligible everyday world, this deep consciousness of nature, healing and helping in sleep and dreams, is at the same time the symbolical analogue of the soothsaying faculty and of the arts generally, which make life possible and worth living...


The Dionysian.

Either under the influence of the narcotic drought, of which the songs of all primitive men and peoples speak, or with the potent coming of spring that penetrates all nature with joy, these Dionysian emotions awake, and as they grow in intensity everything subjective vanishes into complete self-forgetfulness... There are some who, from obtuseness or lack of experience, turn away from such phenomena as from 'folk-diseases,' with contempt or pity born of the consciousness of their own 'healthy-mindedness.' But of course such poor wretches have no idea how corpselike and ghostly their so-called 'healthy-mindedness' looks when the glowing life of the Dionysian revelers roars past them.


Under the charm of the Dionysian not only is the union between man and man reaffirmed, [against the Apollinian principle of individuation] but nature which has been alienated, hostile, or subjugated, celebrates once more her reconciliation with her lost son, man... [The Romantic and the anti-Promethean] Now the slave is a free man; now all the rigid, hostile barriers that necessity, caprice, or 'impudent convention' have fixed between man and man are broken. Now, with the gospel of universal harmony, each one feels himself not only united, reconciled, and fused with his neighbor, but as one with him, as if the veil of māyā had been torn aside and were now merely fluttering in tatters before the mysterious primordial unity. [My emphasis.]


In song and in dance man expresses himself as a member of a higher community... he feels himself a god, he himself now walks about enchanted, in ecstasy, like the gods he saw walking in his dreams. He is no longer an artist, he has become a work of art: in these paroxysms of intoxication the artistic power of all nature reveals itself to the highest gratification of the primordial unity....


Sec 2 - The Dionysian dithyramb

...The very element which forms the essence of Dionysian music (and hence of music in general) is carefully excluded [from the music of Apollo] as un-Apollinian -- namely, the emotional power of the tone, the uniform flow of melody, and the utterly incomparable world of harmony. In the Dionysian dithyramb man is incited to the greatest exaltation of all his symbolic faculties; something never before experienced struggles for utterance -- the annihilation of the veil of māyā, oneness as the soul of the race and of nature itself... With what astonishment must the Apollinian Greek have beheld him! With an astonishment that was all the greater the more it was mingled with the shuddering suspicion that all this was actually not so very alien to him after all, in fact, that it was only his Apollinian consciousness which, like a veil, hid this Dionysian world from his vision.


It's a pity Nietzsche didn't live to witness the Age of Aquarius, he would have been so on-board. Re: Race, or race pride: Race would seem to be an aspect of individuation. It makes sense that a “nation” would share more in common with each other. And what they share would seem to them to also be “right.” Ironically, it requires an other for people to be aware of this racial aspect since left to themselves they would only be aware of their differences. There are other sorts of “nations” as well including religious, and cultural common interests... like this blog. I’m still a bit surprised Nietzsche gives race an almost metaphysical status.

My translation of Nietzsche prefers "Apollinian" while James Miller in The Passion of Michel Foucault goes with "Apollonian," which is also preferred by my spellchecker. I will use each in turn.


Sec 3 - The Olympian gods


...Whoever approaches these Olympians with another religion in his heart, searching among them for moral elevation, even for sanctity, for disincarnate spirituality, for charity and benevolence, will soon be forced to turn his back on them, discouraged and disappointed. For there is nothing here that suggests asceticism, spirituality, or duty. We hear nothing but the accents of an exuberant, triumphant life in which all things, whether good or evil, are deified. [“Beyond good and evil” as Nietzsche will later express it] And so the spectator may stand quite bewildered before this fantastic excess of life, asking himself by virtue of what magic potion these high-spirited men could have found life so enjoyable that, wherever they turned, their eyes beheld the smile of Helen, the ideal picture of their own existence, ‘floating in sweet sensuality...’ [We will come back to Helen in Faust.]

From SparkNotes  (they had the best summary of the Dionysian):

Nietzsche tells the story of King Midas, who finally caught the satyr Silenus and asked him what was the best of all things for man. His answer was, as Nietzsche puts it, "Oh, wretched ephemeral race, children of chance and misery, why do ye compel me to tell you what it were most expedient for you not to hear? What is best of all is beyond your reach forever: not to be born, not to be, to be nothing. But the second best for you—is quickly to die."

Dionysus offered real salvation from suffering, not by covering it up with pretty images, but by absorbing the individual into the great community of the unconscious. In the 'bosom' of Primal Unity, as Nietzsche calls it, man found deliverance from his individual fate, joined as he was to the souls of so many others. Existential suffering is a product of the individual who thinks he suffers alone, and can see no meaning in existence. Dionysus removes the veil from men's eyes, showing them the grand, dark chaos that sits in their hearts, and in the hearts of all men. Dionysus urges man to rejoice in this chaos, to lose himself, and thus to grow beyond his suffering.

It’s hard not to see a desire for “Primal Unity” in both Heidegger’s enthusiasm for Nazism and Foucault’s enthusiasm (and also in the enthusiasm of many other intellectuals who really should have known better) for Communism -- an enthusiasm Foucault renounced only because his sexuality precluded his true participation in the desired “Unity.”


...How is the world of the Olympic gods related to this folk wisdom?...


Now it is as if the Olympic magic mountain [Zauberberg] had opened before us and revealed its roots to us. The Greek knew and felt the terror and horror of existence. That he might endure this terror at all, he had to interpose between himself and life the radiant dreambirth of the Olympians. That overwhelming dismay in the face of the titanic powers of nature, the Moira [fate] enthroned inexorably over all knowledge, the vulture of the great lover of mankind, Prometheus, the terrible fate of the wise Oedipus, the family curse of the Atridae which drove Orestes to matricide: in short, that entire philosophy of the sylvan god, with its mythic exemplars... all this was again and again overcome by the Greeks with the aid of the Olympian middle world of art; or at any rate it was veiled and withdraws from sight. It was in order to be able to live that the Greeks had to create these gods from a most profound need... How else could this people, so sensitive, so vehement in its desires, so singularly capable of suffering, have endured existence, if it had not been revealed to them in their gods, surrounded with a higher glory?


...Thus do the gods justify the life of man: they themselves live it -- the only satisfactory theodicy! Existence under the bright sunshine of such gods is regarded as desirable in itself, and the real pain of Homeric men is caused by parting from it, especially by early parting: so that now, reversing the wisdom of Silenus, we might say of the Greeks that ‘to die soon is worst of all for them... At the Apollinian stage of development, the ‘will’ longs so vehemently for this existence, the Homeric man feels himself so completely at one with it, that lamentation [of the loss of life] itself becomes a song of praise.


Here we should note that this harmony... this oneness of man with nature (for which Schiller introduced the technical term naïve), is by no means a simple condition that comes into being naturally and as if inevitably. It is not a condition that, like a terrestrial paradise, must necessarily be found at the gate of every culture. Only a romantic age would believe this, an age which conceived of the artist it terms of Rousseau’s Emile, reared at the bosom of nature.... [I’m surprised he doesn’t say this is an Aryan trait since the Hindu gods and goddesses are fairly similar in this respect and maybe the Norse gods as well.]

The Homeric 
‘naïveté’ can be understood only as the complete victory of Apollinian illusion... In the Greeks the ‘will’ wished to contemplate itself in the transfiguration of genius and the world of art... This is the sphere of beauty, in which they saw their mirror images, the Olympians. With this mirroring of beauty the Hellenic will combated its artistically correlative talent for suffering and for the wisdom of suffering -- and as a monument of its victory, we have Homer, the naïve artist.